Is Real Estate Investment Tax Loss Carryforward Really Beneficial? The Pitfalls of ‘Tax Savings Through Deficits’ and Points to Note When Selling

9 Min Read


“If you create a deficit through real estate investment, you can get a tax refund on your salary.”
Have you ever received an explanation like that?
The system of tax loss carryforward itself is, of course, a legitimate tax mechanism.
However, I cannot support buying investment condominiums with the primary goal of saving on taxes.

This is because even if your taxes are reduced, if the property’s income and expenditure are poor, your assets will decrease.
What is important is not how much you reduced your taxes, but how much money remains while you own it, and how much it will sell for in the end.
I want you to make sure you don’t get this wrong.

What is tax loss carryforward? Can you get a tax refund if your real estate income is in the red?

Tax loss carryforward is a system where losses incurred from certain types of income are deducted from the profits of other types of income.
For example, if a person with salary income incurs a tax deficit from real estate income through rental management, they may be able to offset it against their salary income if certain conditions are met, which can reduce their income tax burden.
Sometimes, taxes already paid can be refunded.

However, you cannot unconditionally offset all deficits from real estate income.
There are amounts that are excluded, such as deficits corresponding to interest on loans for acquiring land.
This needs to be confirmed according to the actual tax return details.

Bookkeeping deficits and monthly out-of-pocket expenses are different matters

Another thing to distinguish is tax-based profit/loss and cash flow.
Building depreciation is not an expense where that amount of cash leaves your pocket every year.
Therefore, even if you are in the red for tax purposes, you may still have cash on hand.
On the other hand, loan principal repayments usually involve cash leaving your pocket even if they are not deductible expenses.
Conversely, it can happen that even if your tax return shows a profit, your monthly cash on hand is negative.
I would like you to first look at how much is actually leaving your bank account.

Reasons why I do not recommend buying deficit-ridden properties for tax savings

Among those who consult me about selling, there are people who say, “I was told it would save on taxes when I bought it, but the effect didn’t last as long as I thought.”
In the first year, there are expenses associated with acquisition, so the calculated deficit may look large.
However, that does not necessarily continue every year.
A few years later, the tax reduction effect has diminished, but the monthly out-of-pocket expenses remain the same.
That is when they start thinking about selling.

As a property ages, rents may decrease, and equipment replacement or repair costs may arise.
The burden of management fees and repair reserve funds can also change.
I believe it is difficult to turn around a property that has had tight cash flow since the time of purchase just by using tax savings.
Even if your taxes are slightly reduced, it is meaningless if more money is going out than that.

Do not decide on the allocation of depreciation based solely on the sales company’s explanation

When I look at past tax returns during sales consultations, I sometimes feel that the way the building and equipment costs are separated needs to be verified.
This is because the calculation of depreciation can change depending on the amount recorded as equipment.
Some people have just used the figures presented at the time of sale.
In such cases, I recommend having a tax accountant check it, including the basis for the figures.
If there are errors in the tax return, corrections may be necessary.

If you lose money on a sale, can you offset it against your salary income?

This is a point that is particularly prone to misunderstanding.
The “real estate income deficit” from rental management and the “capital loss” when selling an investment condominium are different things.
Even if you incur a loss from selling investment land or buildings, in principle, you cannot offset it against salary income or similar.
While it may be deductible against capital gains from other land or buildings, it cannot be treated the same as a deficit from rental management.

Furthermore, the tax calculation for whether a profit was made on a sale is not a simple “difference between purchase price and sale price.”
Calculations such as deducting the equivalent of building depreciation from the acquisition cost are necessary.
It is dangerous to decide to sell by looking only at past tax savings effects.
Gather the contracts and tax returns from the time of acquisition and check the tax outlook before selling.

Can an investment condominium bought at a deficit not be sold?

“Since it’s a property that is in the red every month, won’t there be no buyers?”
I also receive consultations like this.
However, the property itself is not necessarily bad.
This is because the income and expenditure for each owner differ depending on how much they bought it for, what interest rate they borrowed at, and how much of their own funds they put in.

The next buyer will judge based on their own financial plan, actual rent, management fees, repair reserve funds, and future expenses.
That is why it is important to know a reasonable price in the current market, rather than just using the amount the seller purchased it for as a benchmark.
I understand the desire to “sell for as high a price as possible.”
However, if the income and expenditure do not make sense to the next buyer, the deal will not close.

For real estate investment, prioritize cash on hand over tax savings

Tax loss carryforward in real estate investment is something to be used with a correct understanding of the system; creating a deficit itself is not the purpose of investment.
I believe that real estate investment is about protecting assets and nurturing them over a long period of time.

If you are currently struggling with the income and expenditure of a studio apartment you bought for tax saving purposes, first try organizing your actual cash flow, remaining loan balance, and current market price for sale.
Can you improve it by continuing to hold it, or can you reduce the burden by selling it?
It is important to judge by looking at the final cash on hand, not the tax refund amount.


The TOCHU official column introduces in detail the types of deficits, points to note regarding tax loss carryforward, and methods for improving income and expenditure.
Monthly deficit in real estate investment!? What are the countermeasures and ways of thinking about tax loss carryforward?

For how to deal with cases where depreciation or tax saving effects do not continue, please also refer to this.
“Real estate investment does not save on taxes” – is it true?

The way of thinking about tax loss carryforward and points to note regarding investment products that emphasize tax savings are also explained on YouTube in “Mr. Ito’s Investment Condominium Sales Cram School.”
Related YouTube video

If you are considering holding or selling an investment condominium, please also see the official website of TOCHU Co., Ltd.
TOCHU Co., Ltd. Official Website



Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment