Last time, I wrote about how I started taking on real estate investment.
This time, I would like to write about an apartment building that I considered to the point of thinking, “I might actually buy this,” for the first time.
The property was a wooden apartment building located within the Kanto region, less than a 10-minute walk from the station. It had 6 units in total, and the price was approximately 25 million yen. The gross yield was about 8%.
I went to see the site, checked with the brokerage firm multiple times, and even considered price negotiations, but in the end, I decided not to purchase it.
However, by seriously considering this property, my thinking regarding real estate investment became much clearer.
Although I didn’t buy it in the end, it was a property that served as a very good learning experience in my search for my first building.
At first, I thought, “This might actually be pretty good”
One of the reasons I was interested in this property was its location.
It was within a 10-minute walk from the nearest station.
When starting real estate investment, I want to prioritize “proximity to the station” as much as possible.
Even if the building gets old, the land and the location remain.
Whether I sell it in the future or rebuild it, I thought it might leave more options open than a property far from the station.
That was the thinking I had.
Furthermore, when I looked into the surrounding land prices, it seemed like the land value was reasonably high relative to the property price.
“The building is old, but if there is land value, isn’t it not so bad?”
That was my initial impression.
My impression changed when I saw the site
While I was looking at the documents, I felt it was reasonably attractive.
However, when I actually went to the site, my impression changed.
To be honest, my first impression was,
“It’s older than I thought…”
That was my impression.
You can tell the age of the building by looking at the documents.
However, the age of the building as seen in numbers is completely different from the actual age of the building seen with your own eyes.
It didn’t seem like large-scale repairs were needed immediately, but the brokerage firm also told me that I should expect to set aside about 1.5 to 2 million yen for the roof, exterior walls, and balcony waterproofing in the future.
If it’s an entire apartment building, that cost is naturally the owner’s responsibility.
I will write about this later, but the annual cash flow after financing for this property is about 400,000 to 600,000 yen. In other words, just one round of repairs would wipe out 3 to 4 years’ worth of cash flow in calculations.
If you only look at the gross yield, this kind of sense for the reality of the situation tends to slip away.
When you take out a loan, the way you see the numbers changes
This time, the brokerage firm also introduced me to a lender.
The conditions were to borrow 70-80% of the property price, with a 30-year term and a variable interest rate in the high 4% range.
The initial costs, including my own funds and various expenses, were about 7 million yen. When simulating with these conditions, the annual cash flow after deducting operating expenses and repayments was about 400,000 to 600,000 yen.
It is a figure that “works, at least.”
However, what concerned me was the variable interest rate.
For example, if you borrow 20 million yen for 30 years at an interest rate of 4.8%, the annual repayment amount for equal principal and interest repayment is about 1.26 million yen.
If this interest rate becomes 5.8%, the annual repayment amount becomes about 1.41 million yen.
Just a 1% increase in interest rates means an increase in annual repayment burden of about 150,000 yen.
For a property with an annual cash flow of 400,000 to 600,000 yen, an additional burden of 150,000 yen per year is not small.
If the cash flow is 400,000 yen, nearly 40% of that would be wiped out just by the interest rate increase.
Furthermore, what would happen if repairs on the scale of 1.5 to 2 million yen and an interest rate increase occurred at the same time?
Thinking about it that way, the “8% gross yield” figure I saw at first started to look like a very different landscape.
“Just raising the rent” is not that simple
There were tenants in this property who had been living there for a long time at quite low rents.
On the other hand, higher rents were set for units being advertised for new tenants.
At first, I thought,
“If the tenants change, couldn’t I gradually raise the rent?”
I considered that as well.
However, when I looked into surrounding rental properties, there were naturally apartments that were closer to the station and nicer than this one.
Tenants don’t decide on a room by looking only at my property.
If I raise the rent, it will be compared with competing properties in that price range.
In other words,
“current low rent does not equal easy to raise rent”
is not the case.
It’s obvious, but when I actually considered purchasing, I understood the meaning of this well.
Think of “planned” and “actual” separately
At the time I was considering it, one of the six units was vacant, and I was told there was someone planning to move in.
If they move in as planned, the building will be fully occupied, and the yield will increase slightly. The brokerage company also explained that “there is potential for the yield to rise to nearly 10% if all units can be filled at the advertised rent.”
However, I thought about that for a moment.
“What if they don’t move in as planned?”
In real estate investment, shouldn’t I think of “what is planned to happen” and “what is already the case now” separately?
I feel this is similar to stock investment.
Rather than buying by factoring in all expectations of what might happen in the future,
does it work as an investment in its current state?
I have come to think that it is important to use this as a standard for consideration.
The thing that concerned me most was the “exit”
And, ultimately, what I was most concerned about was the exit.
This property had some aspects regarding road access that required verification.
Even if it wouldn’t be a major issue if I just operated the current building as is, in the future,
・rebuilding
・selling
・clearing the land
would change the situation.
As the building gets older, demolition will eventually become necessary.
How much will the demolition costs be?
Will there be any additional costs unique to old buildings?
Will there be any problems when rebuilding?
Will there be buyers when selling it as land?
When I thought that far,
“The land value is decent, so it should be fine”
I think my initial way of thinking was a bit optimistic.
My valuation kept dropping from 25 million yen
The asking price was about 25 million yen.
At first,
“I might consider it if it were about 3 million yen cheaper”
I thought.
However, the more I researched, the lower my internal valuation of the property became.
Even if it were another 2 million yen cheaper,
“Is this really cheap even at this price?”
I began to feel.
Here, I realized one major thing.
It’s not that I want it if the price goes down, but do I actually want this property in the first place?
That is what it comes down to.
Investments have prices.
Even a good property is not an investment target if it is too expensive.
Conversely, even a property with some issues might be an investment target if it is sufficiently cheap.
This sense felt very natural to me, having done stock investing.
Rethinking before submitting a purchase offer
The brokerage firm told me that if I wanted to negotiate the price specifically, I should submit a purchase offer with my desired price written on it.
Once it gets to this point, the purchase suddenly becomes realistic.
So I asked myself again.
“If the price drops to my desired level, do I really want to buy this property?”
The answer was ambiguous.
Even before considering whether price negotiations would succeed, I wasn’t fully convinced by the property myself.
In that case, there was no need to force a purchase offer.
Ultimately, I decided to pass on the purchase this time.
The fact that I ‘didn’t buy’ was also a valuable experience
When you start real estate investment,
I want to buy my first building as soon as possible
the feeling of wanting to do this inevitably arises.
I feel the same way myself.
Searching for properties, communicating with brokerage firms, and going to see them in person.
Once you’ve spent this much time,
the feeling of
Since I’ve already researched this much, I should buy it
also emerges. However, the goal of investment is not ‘to buy real estate’.
It is to acquire assets under good conditions.
By passing on this one, the conditions I seek for my first building have actually become clearer than before.
・As close to the station as possible ・Has land value ・Can imagine an exit strategy ・Cash flow remains even after using financing ・Can grasp major repair risks ・Works without being optimistic about rent increases ・Can buy with personal conviction
I want to cherish these points in future property selection as well.
Don’t rush precisely because it’s the first building
This property became the first apartment building I seriously considered buying.
In the end, I didn’t buy it.
However, strangely enough, I have no regrets.
By visiting the site, researching land values, checking market rents, and considering loan terms, repair costs, and exit strategies, I feel my perspective on real estate has changed just a little.
Compared to when I was just browsing property listings online, the number of points I look at has increased significantly.
And what I felt most strongly this time is,
that the decision to “not buy” is also a valid investment decision.
With stocks, it’s relatively easy to decide to “pass this time,” but when it comes to real estate, the desire to buy that first building tends to take precedence.
That is precisely why I intend to take my time and search for a property I can be truly satisfied with.
My journey into real estate investment has only just begun.
Will the next one be my first building?
I will continue my search for properties.
