Tim Croak, CEO and Founder, Croak Capital. Financial advisor specializing in retirement and legacy planning.
Americans have never wanted more financial advice. They’ve also never had a harder time getting it.
According to a 2025 McKinsey report, demand for human financial guidance grew three times faster than the U.S. population from 2015 to 2024, with fee-based advisory revenues surging from $150 billion in 2015 to $260 billion in 2024. Yet McKinsey projects that the wealth management industry could find itself roughly 100,000 financial advisors short of what’s needed by 2034. Into that gap, a new generation of AI-powered, self-directed financial planning tools is rushing in. The question is: Can they fill it?
After 43 years as a financial advisor, I have seen the good, the bad and the ugly of my profession. I’ve also seen the benefits, frustrations and shortcomings of the technological world, most of which center on a single persistent blind spot: the human condition. Discipline. Follow-through. The ability to understand not just a person’s portfolio, but their fears, their goals, their timelines and the roadblocks they may not yet see coming.
What AI Does Well
The advances in robo-advisors and AI-powered planning tools are real. For millions of Americans who have never had access to professional financial guidance, these tools are a genuine on-ramp. They democratize the fundamentals: dollar-cost averaging, portfolio rebalancing, low-cost ETF investing, buying at market dips and understanding basic allocation strategy. They let people look at, control and take responsibility for their own financial lives, often for the first time. The importance of bringing this information to more people cannot be overstated. AI is a powerful equalizer in financial literacy.
Where AI Falls Short
But from my perspective, there is a ceiling. And it arrives the moment financial planning stops being about numbers and starts being about life.
A mentor of mine said it best: Go to the internet for information, but go to a human being for judgment, perspective and guidance. That distinction has never been more relevant than today. No person should be reduced to a template, a boilerplate, an assumption or an algorithm. Knowledge is what you acquire. Wisdom is what a good advisor offers, and wisdom is something altogether different. It is knowledge metabolized through experience, mindfully shared for the common good.
Wisdom operates at a higher level. It understands context. It is more than smart; it is intelligent. It carries an inherent humility. It is shared, not imposed. There is no ego involved. Those who are truly wise never claim to be. They understand that pain is part of the living process and that painful life lessons are the raw material for growth. They know there are no absolutes.
The wise also understand something AI will never grasp: that our deepest human fear is irrelevance. Money is not an end. It is a tool, a means to find meaning, to create impact, to build a life that matters. Financial advising at its best is mentorship. It is as much spiritual as it is practical.
The Human Advantage
A great advisor does not simply manage portfolios. They offer empathy, encouragement and a nuanced understanding of complex life situations that no algorithm can replicate. They read between the lines. They provide accountability. High-functioning advisory firms offer access to private investments, sophisticated tax planning and multigenerational wealth strategy—through the lens of the individual human being. Robo-advisors offer data-driven optimization. Human advisors offer a framework for a richer life.
A Practical Path Forward
The question is not AI versus human advisors; it is knowing when each serves you best. For many people starting out, AI can be a helpful first step. They can use it to build a portfolio, establish saving habits and learn the fundamentals.
When life grows more complex—be that through a business, an inheritance, a divorce, retirement on the horizon, children to educate, a legacy to protect—that is when human judgment becomes especially important. At that stage you deserve a team of dedicated professionals working on your behalf every day. Not a template. A relationship built on trust, experience and the wisdom that only comes from sitting with real people through the full arc of their financial lives.
The future of wealth management is not a choice between technology and humanity. It is the intelligent use of both, with the wisdom to know which one the moment calls for.
The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Finance Council is an invitation-only organization for executives in successful accounting, financial planning and wealth management firms. Do I qualify?
